Linnaean Society of New York Regular Meeting Minutes—September 9, 2025

This meeting and presentation took place both in person at the Liederkranz Club and concurrently online via Zoom.

At 7:04 pm, board member Gillian Henry began by welcoming all attendees to this first in-person meeting since the COVID-19 pandemic.

Gillian made the following announcements:

Membership renewals are due for the 2025/2026 year. They can be paid online via the link that has been provided in the email communications to all members. Alternatively, they can be paid by check and mailed. (For directions go to https://www.linnaeannewyork.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/2025-Renewal-by-Mail-Form.pdf).

The fall field trips have started and are listed on the Society’s website.

The homecoming picnic is being held on September 21st (with a rain date of September 28th) at Summit Rock in Central Park.

Next month’s regular members meeting will be not be held on a Tuesday as is customary, but rather on Wednesday, October 15th. It will again be held in person at the Liederkranz Club at 6 East 87th Street and will be concurrently streamed via Zoom.

The Society still needs to fill the vacant position of president. Gillian encouraged anyone who might be interested in serving as president to let a member of the board know.

Until the position of president is filled, board members and past presidents will be taking turns running the Society meetings. The October regular members meeting will be led by Board Member Richard Davis.

Gillian next welcomed 33 new members to the Linnaean Society:

Aubrey Almanza
Timothy Baird
Z Baird
Benjamin Bolduc
Elizabeth Braswell
Stephan Chenault
Teresa Colaizzo
Christine Connelly
Bob Curtis
Peter Drummond
Richard Dundy
Rory Edge
Pepper Evans
Andrea Fondulas
Brian Fox
Eric Frawley
Kristopher John
Anna Kressbach
Isaac Kresse
Hilli Kushnir
Vuong Mai
Nina Molina
Lisa Nasta
Eve Oppenheim
Diego Orlanski
Catherine Pan-Giordano
Michael Peczynski
Sandra Power
David Sgorbati
Nancy Taubenslag
Marta Torres Quiñones
Denise Vacva
Liam Wager

At 7:09 pm, Gillian turned to the lecture program and introduced the night’s speaker, Dr. Erik Katovich, assistant professor in the Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics at the University of Connecticut.

Lecture: “How Do Wind Turbines and Oil and Gas Infrastructure Affect Birds? Empirical Evidence Based on Citizen-science Data,” presented by Dr. Erik Katovich

Dr. Katovich is an economist whose research focuses on “natural resource governance and the effects of resource booms and energy transitions on governments, firms, workers, and the environment.” And, he is a birder. Having a background in both, and because of recent media attention to claims about the effects of wind turbines on birds, he became interested in doing a study to help answer if, and by how much, wind turbines affect birds, and how that compares to the impact of gas and oil extraction by fracking.

Dr. Katovich explained that the energy sector has been changing rapidly over the past 20 years, with shale gas production increasing 20-fold between the years 2007 to 2020, and wind turbine production increasing 48-fold from the years 2000 to 2020. Also, these technologies use a lot of land and may have potentially consequential environmental impacts. Among the examples that he noted is the increase in light pollution from fracking operations, illustrated by a nighttime satellite image of North America. Some of the largest and brightest areas were in North Dakota, Wyoming, Texas, and Pennsylvania, where fracking sites are concentrated, compared to pinpoints of fainter light from the largest cities, including Los Angeles and New York.   

Using data from the 2000 through 2020 National Audubon Society Christmas Bird Counts in the lower 48 states and statistical methods of econometrics, Dr. Katovich explained his analysis of the impact of wind turbines and shale gas and oil operations on bird population numbers and bird species diversity. He presented figures and graphs to illustrate many aspects of his study and conclusions (with caveats that this study is looking at population levels­—it does not address bird collisions or avoidance behaviors):

After a shale oil/gas well is built, overall bird population numbers decline by 15%. Largest effects are seen on grassland/shrubland birds (a 24% decline), non-urban birds (a 23% decline), and migratory birds (a 37% decline).

After the installation of wind turbines, there are no statistically significant changes in bird population numbers or species counts.

When considering the effect of density (number) of shale wells or turbines built, results are similar but more negative for wells, particularly on species diversity. A 10% increase in fracking wells reduces bird counts by 0.26% (3.6 birds per well).

Breaking down the results by taxonomic orders produces the following:

Shale oil/gas wells: largest negative effects are for Strigiformes (owls), but other groups are negatively affected as well: Piciformes (woodpeckers), Falconiformes (falcons), Pelecaniformes (bitterns, etc.), Accipitriformes (hawks, etc.), and Passeriformes.

Wind turbines: no effect, including for Accipitriformes.

Shale wells: Negative effects persist after shale well installations.

Wind turbines: No negative effects persist after wind turbine installations.

Shale wells within IBAs (Important Bird Areas, identified by National Audubon Society): negative effects are larger when wells are within IBAs.

Wind turbines within IBAs: no effects.

He summarized the key takeaways:

Fracking significantly reduces bird populations.

Fracking reduces bird diversity where shale oil/gas wells are located within IBAs.

Wind turbines have no measurable impact on bird populations or diversity.

Dr. Katovich concluded by noting that we need energy as a society; that there are choices to be made about how it is produced; that each method has its own set of impacts on wildlife; and that we should be working to minimize those impacts. His final slide presented suggestions for what can be done with both fracking and wind turbine infrastructure to minimize harm to birds.

Following is Dr. Katovich’s abstract of his talk:

Rapid expansion of wind turbines and oil and gas fracking infrastructure has raised concerns over impacts on wildlife, especially birds. I combine citizen-science data from the National Audubon Society’s Christmas Bird Count with registries of all the turbines and shale oil and gas wells constructed in the United States between 2000 and 2020 to quantify the effects of turbine or shale well construction on local bird populations and biodiversity. In my talk, I will review the current scientific evidence on environmental impacts of wind and oil and gas infrastructure, describe the data and methods I use in my study, explain my results, and discuss options for reducing impacts of energy infrastructure on wildlife.

At 7:47 pm, Vice President for Programming Karen Becker thanked Dr. Katovich for a fascinating talk. She then hosted the Q&A session, starting with questions from the Liederkranz audience, and concluded with questions submitted via the Zoom Q&A function.

Following the conclusion of the Q&A, Karen Becker thanked Dr. Katovich again for an utterly fascinating talk and for leaving the audience with a note of optimism. At 8:20 pm the meeting was adjourned.

Dr. Erik Katovich’s presentation and the Q&A session have been recorded in their entirety, along with Board Member Gillian Henry’s opening meeting remarks. The recording is available for viewing on the Linnaean Society of New York website under the dropdown menu: Programs/Watch/ and on the Society’s YouTube channel, https://www.youtube.com/@linnaeanny/videos

Respectfully submitted by Lisa Kroop, Recording Secretary

Linnaean Society of New York Regular Meeting Minutes—May 13, 2025

This meeting and presentation took place entirely online via Zoom.

At 7:00 pm, Treasurer and Past President Debbie Mullins called the Society meeting to order.

Debbie made the following announcements:

This is the last meeting of this program year.

The next regular members meeting will be held on September 9, 2025.

The Linnaean-organized Great Gull Island birdathon was held this past weekend and was a great success. A total of nine teams and individuals competed. There had been some high migration nights, so there was an abundance of birds. Results of the birdathon will be posted on the website later this month or in early June.

Despite the hazards of brightly illuminated buildings that confront migrating birds, the New York City Council failed to pass the Lights Out legislation that would require buildings to reduce exterior lighting during bird migration. Debbie noted that as individuals, we can all help mitigate the impact of light on birds by closing our blinds and turning off exterior lights on high migration nights. The BirdCast bird migration website provides nightly updates of migration intensity in local areas.

Debbie next welcomed eleven new members to the Linnaean Society:

Maureen Crilly
Daniel Deutsch
Anne Green
Anita Keire
Jessica Kirk
Scott Klavan
Mike Maxfield
Henar Minguez Nebreda
Jessica Newman
Concetta Pilotto
Joan Simpson Klavan


She invited all attendees who are not members to join, explaining that membership information can be found on the Society’s website at www.linnaeannewyork.org.

At 7:03 pm, Debbie turned to the lecture program and invited Vice President of Programming Karen Becker to introduce the night’s speaker, Judith Mirembe, a bird guide and researcher working in Uganda. She founded Shoebill Watch Uganda, a non-profit organization focused on protecting the Shoebill and other species. She is the Pioneer Chairperson and a founding member of the Uganda Women Birders Club, the editor of a newsletter about birding in Uganda called the Birdwatch, and she has worked with Nature Uganda as the research and monitoring coordinator of Ugandan bird populations.

Lecture: “In the World of Shoebills: The King of the African Wetlands,” presented by Judith Mirembe

Judith Mirembe joined the Society’s meeting from Uganda, where local time was 2:00 am. She began her talk by introducing the audience to the Shoebill, a bird that is endemic to a limited range in tropical central Africa—in Uganda and adjacent countries. She described these remarkable birds, which are classified as a monotypic family in the pelican order, and supplemented her commentary with photographs and videos.  Though its plumage is mainly gray, the Shoebill is an exotic-looking bird with an enormous bill of unusual shape. It is large, standing around five feet tall with a wingspan almost twice its height and weighing between 10 and 15 pounds.

The Shoebill’s habitat is in low oxygenated freshwater wetlands with floating vegetation that is strong enough to support the bird’s weight. Ms. Mirembe spoke about the bird’s foraging habits. It waits motionless for long periods of time until a lungfish (its most common prey) comes up to breathe. Then the Shoebill lunges for it, crushing the fish with its powerful bill, and swallows it whole.

She also talked about the bird’s breeding. Nest building starts near the end of the rainy season, when the water level is dropping and dry patches are exposed. One to three eggs are laid, though she has usually seen only one. She said that in Uganda only about 30% of chicks survive beyond the egg stage, and only about 40% of the chicks fledge; this phenomenon is worrying and not fully understood. Some possible factors include the pressure from warming temperatures due to climate change, resulting in habitat loss; wetlands conversion for agriculture and other development; and the poaching of eggs and chicks to supply the international illegal wildlife trade (the Shoebill is listed under Article 2 of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species, CITES).

Ms. Mirembe concluded with a mention of the International Single Species Action Plan for the Conservation of the Shoebill, issued in 2013. The Plan is directed at all nations where Shoebills have been seen. It summarizes what is known about Shoebills, and identifies the information that is still needed to help protect the species from further decline. (The current population is estimated at between 5,000 and 8,000 birds and is classified as “Vulnerable” by the International Union for Conservation of Nature, IUCN). She noted that the Plan was scheduled to be revisited every ten years, but this has not yet happened, and many of the recommendations from 2013 have not been implemented due to inadequate funding.

At 7:41 pm, Vice President of Programming Karen Becker thanked Judith Mirembe for her talk about a fascinating bird that lives in an interesting part of the world. She then hosted the Q&A session. There were many questions, some specific to Shoebills, others to birding in Uganda and conservation. When someone observed that there seems to be a strong community of female birding guides in Uganda, she recounted the history of the country’s evolution from barely any women birders and guides to the formation of the Uganda Women’s Birders’ Club in 2013, and the support of the Ugandan Wildlife Authority and international travel companies that enabled local women to be trained and mentored so they could participate in Uganda’s ecotourism economy.

At the conclusion of the Q&A, Karen Becker thanked Judith Mirembe again for an incredible talk sharing her research and passion for Shoebills and about women in birding, and at 8:17 pm the meeting was adjourned.

Judith Mirembe’s presentation and the Q&A session have been recorded in their entirety, along with Past President Debbie Mullin’s opening meeting remarks. The recording is available for viewing on the Linnaean Society of New York website under the dropdown menu: Programs/Watch/ and on the Society’s YouTube channel, https://www.youtube.com/@linnaeanny/videos

Respectfully submitted by Lisa Kroop, Recording Secretary

Linnaean Society of New York Regular Meeting Minutes—April 8, 2025

This meeting and presentation took place entirely online via Zoom.

At 7:00 pm, Past President Ken Chaya called the Society meeting to order.

Ken made the following announcements:

  • He welcomed all to the meeting.
  • He welcomed the new members to the Linnaean Society:
    • Amy Chai
    • Catherine Crean
    • Jordan Douglas
    • Sheila Martin
    • Maria Mercurio
    • Judith Schechter
    • Laurel Nadler
    • Benjamin Smith
    • Jeffrey Train
    • Joe Zimmerman
  • He invited all who are not members to join, explaining that membership information and directions for joining are on the Society’s website.
  • The Tuesday morning spring migration walks in Central Park have begun. In addition to the Central Park walks, there are many other scheduled field trips. Ken invited everyone to visit the Society’s website for the listings and registration.
  • The Great Gull Island birdathon is being held on May 10-11. It is a fundraiser event run by the Society in support of the study and protection of nesting Roseate and Common Tern colonies on this very special island. Information about participation in the birdathon is on the Society’s website.

At 7:03 pm, Ken turned to the lecture program and introduced the night’s speaker, Dr. Anurag Agrawal, James Perkins Professor of Environmental Studies at Cornell University in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology and the Department of Entomology.

Lecture: “Convergence and Divergence in the Diversity of Insects Feeding on a Toxic Plant,” presented by Dr. Anurag Agrawal

Tonight’s lecture was a captivating presentation on milkweeds, monarch butterflies, and the conservation of this iconic butterfly species.

Starting with a description of the monarch butterfly, Dr. Agrawal explained that like all members of the Lepidoptera (an order of winged insects that includes butterflies and moths), it goes through a two-stage transformation from the caterpillar stage (a “feeding machine”) to the butterfly stage (the adult, more mobile, mating phase). In addition, the vast majority of the monarch species undertake an extraordinary migratory journey from central Mexico to the northeast United States and southeast Canada, and back again. (Some population pockets elsewhere do not migrate). Using a circular graphical representation, Dr. Agrawal described the annual cycle of the monarch’s migration. As we are currently in April, he started with that point on the wheel. The monarchs have left their overwintering sites and are reaching the southern United States, where they mate and the females lay eggs, starting the first generation. Each generation goes through four life stages: 1) egg, 2) larva (caterpillar), 3) pupa (chrysalis), and 4) adult (butterfly). The butterflies of this first generation will continue to fly north, mating and laying eggs from which the next (second) generation begins. This process repeats for a total of three to four generations. With the exception of the final generation, the adult butterflies live for about one month. As the fall season approaches, the final generation, receiving environmental cues of shorter daylight, cooler nights, and dried milkweed leaves, will go into reproductive diapause. Their wings and wing muscles will be smaller than those of the previous generations, their reproductive organs will not develop, and their flight direction will turn south. Travelling at a rate of 30 to 50 miles per day over distances of 1,500 to 3,000 miles, they will reach their overwintering sites in forested mountains around 30 miles from Mexico City. They will spend the next eight months, fairly dormant, perched primarily on oyamel fir trees, at an elevation of 10,000 feet. Warmer temperatures and lengthening daylight cue them to begin their journey north, starting the cycle over again with a new first generation.

Dr. Agrawal explained that the only host plants of the monarchs are the milkweeds (genus Asclepias), and that milkweed and monarchs have coevolved. Milkweed has developed defenses with physical barriers such as trichomes (leaf hairs) that help protect the leaves from being eaten, and chemical toxins such as cardiac glycosides that are present in the latex of the plants. Monarchs have coevolved with genetics and strategies to overcome the physical barriers of the plant and to survive the toxic effects of the cardiac glycosides. Dr. Agrawal showed a photo of a monarch larva excavating a milkweed leaf to form a trichome-free area for feeding, and photos of examples of toxic-free zones where monarch larvae had chewed leaf veins, thereby stopping the toxic latex flow. That’s not to say that all monarch larvae survive this tactic—30 to 40% are poisoned and die—but the remaining ones not only survive the poison, they pack it away into their bodies and ultimately into their wings as a defense against their own predators. He gave the example of the Blue Jay, a bird that learns that eating a monarch will result in vomiting soon after—12 minutes, in fact—as reproducibly demonstrated in experiments by Lincoln Brower, a researcher well known for his work on monarch butterflies and his “barfing Blue Jays.” During the Q&A session we learned that there are other birds, however, that have adapted to successfully eat monarch butterflies, one being the Black-headed Grosbeak.

Dr. Agrawal devoted the final section of his talk to the conservation of monarch butterflies. He stated outright, “Folks, any way you slice it, monarch butterflies are declining,” and then he presented a chart showing census data of wintering monarchs in Mexico from the early 1990s to the present. The trend tracks downward until around 2015, after which it levels off, suggesting, at least for now, a stabilization of the population. Nevertheless, population decline is concerning, and understanding the reasons for the decline are critical to protecting the monarchs. Dr. Agrawal provided five lessons from his ongoing research and evaluation of the scientific literature:

  1. The importance of butterfly loss (disjunction) during the migration from the northern breeding regions to the overwintering ones is not fully understood. Habitat loss, lack of nectar plants, and lethal collisions with vehicles are among some of the possible factors.
  2. The monarch butterfly population fluctuates broadly and appears to be strongly influenced by regional climate from year-to-year.
  3. Parasites and predators play a large role in monarch populations and have links to their decline.
  4. Sublethal effects of pesticides, fungicides, and herbicides are impacting monarch populations.
  5. Planting native milkweeds has positive benefits, but data analysis has shown that milkweed availability is not a limiting factor, and this approach will not solve monarch population decline.

He emphasized that the decline of monarch butterflies is part of a much larger problem that is impacting many long distance migrating species.

Dr. Agrawal concluded by acknowledging the generous publicly-funded support that he has received through the National Science Foundation over the past twenty years. He noted that the National Science Foundation has been a critical fuel for the greatness of American science, and he hopes that it will continue.

At 7:51 pm, Vice President of Programming Karen Becker thanked Dr. Agrawal for an utterly fascinating talk. She then hosted the Q&A session, which covered many subjects, ranging from how the monarchs navigate to considerations about conservation, and more.

At the conclusion of the Q&A, Karen Becker thanked Dr. Agrawal again, and Ken Chaya returned to thank Dr. Agrawal for a wonderful talk. At 8:21 pm the meeting was adjourned.

Dr. Agrawal’s presentation and the Q&A session have been recorded in their entirety, along with Past President Ken Chaya’s opening meeting remarks. The recording is available for viewing on the Linnaean Society of New York website under the dropdown menu: Programs/Watch/ and on the Society’s YouTube channel, https://www.youtube.com/@linnaeanny/videos

Respectfully submitted by Lisa Kroop, Recording Secretary

The Linnaean Society of New York Annual Meeting Minutes—March 11, 2025

This meeting and presentation took place entirely in person at the Liederkranz Club at 6 East 87th Street, New York.

    The evening began with a reception at 6 pm. This was a members-only event, and it was well-attended by the membership and invited guests. Between members, invited guests, and award winners, around one hundred people began filling the room with the sounds of conversation and laughter, which got louder as more people arrived.

    At 7:36 pm, President Debbie Mullins called the Society meeting to order.

    President Mullins welcomed the audience to this 147th annual meeting of the Linnaean Society of New York and thanked all for coming. She noted that the annual meeting gives the president the opportunity to report on the activities of the Society over the past year, and that she would be presenting those as well as the finances of the past year, the nominees for the Society’s board for the new term, 2025/2026, and the recipients of this year’s Society’s awards.

    President Mullins made the following remarks:

    In Memoriam

    • She gave tribute to all the Society members who have recently passed away and the year in which they joined.
    • Michael Bonifanti, 2016
    • Helen Hays, past president, 1958
    • Orlando H. Garrido, Honorary Member, 2010*
    • Jean Held, 1977
    • Leo Hollein, 2003
    • Anthony Lauro, 1968
    • Nina Moinester, 2007
    • Paul Meyers, 1970
    • Bernard Nathan, 1974
    • Irene Payne, 1999
    • Alison Rea, 2013
    • William Riley, 1965*
    • Ruby Senie, 2019
    • Olaf Soltau, 2016
    • Lenore Swenson, fellow, 1994
    • Constance Wiley, 2021

    *After the annual meeting, the Society’s board learned of their deaths.

    • She noted that Helen Hays, who died a few weeks ago, was a former president of the Society. She was a guiding light for the Great Gull Island project over the decades, beginning in the 1960s, and retired only a few years ago. She will be greatly missed.

    Annual Report

    • The 2024 annual report was distributed to all members in attendance. It contains the secretary’s report and reports from all the Society’s committees. The president encouraged the members to read them.
    • Thirty new members joined the Society in 2024, bringing the membership to 767—almost double the number from before the COVID-19 pandemic.
    • The requirements that new members be sponsored and approved by a vote of the membership have been discontinued.
    • The Society’s fiscal position is strong, with a current balance of $214,000. Last year’s net income was $26,000.
    • The board is looking into the logistics of returning to in-person regular member meetings as a hybrid together with remote attendance via Zoom. Numerous members have been expressing their hope for in-person meetings.
    • The president presented highlights from each of the committee’s accomplishments over the past year, and thanked the chairs, committee members, and volunteers for their dedication and hard work.
    • The president expressed her appreciation and thanks to the outgoing board members whose terms are ending.
    • The president mentioned others who have contributed to the Society’s infrastructure, operations, and growth. And she thanked those on the planning committee for arranging this annual meeting.
    • She concluded by expressing that it had been a privilege to serve as president for the past two years, and thanked the Society for its support.

    Silent Auction and Raffle

    • Gillian Henry presented the results of the silent auction, and drew the tickets for the winners of the raffle bags.

    Election of Officers, Board Members, and Motions

    • Alice Deutsch, Mary Beth Kooper, and Kevin Sisco comprised the committee for nominating officers and board members.
    • Thus far, a presidential candidate has not been found, and the search continues for a person who would be interested in filling the role. In the interim, board members and former presidents will share the responsibilities.
    • President Mullins then introduced the officers and board members who have been nominated for election.
    • Voting will be done online: following the meeting, ballots will be emailed to all members who are up-to-date with their dues. The poll will be open for two days, and close on Thursday, March 13th, at midnight.

    Awards

    • Member awards:
      • Peregrine Falcon 50-year Member Award to Paula M. Schutte, who joined the Linnaean Society in 1975.
      • Fellow to Ken Chaya, former president, vice president, board member, and trip leader, who provided a great deal of dedicated service to the Linnaean Society, including during the COVID lockdown, when he kept the Society vibrant and moving forward.
    • Linnaean Society of New York awards: The Society presents several awards each year to honor individuals who have made significant contributions to natural history, conservation, and education. President Mullins introduced each honoree and described and recognized their achievements:
      • 2025 Shelda Taylor Award to Jennifer Stalec, a teacher at Eleanor Roosevelt High School. The award honors K – 12 teachers who have made a sustained and substantial impact by educating their students on aspects of natural history.
      • 2025 Natural History Service Award to Dustin Partridge, director of conservation and science at the NYC Bird Alliance, for his research and expertise on green infrastructure in urban landscapes. This award is given to individuals who, through working with members of the public, have triggered a lasting interest in natural history.
      • 2025 Eisenmann Medal to Bryan D. Watts, the Mitchell A. Byrd Professor of Conservation Biology at the College of William & Mary. He is the founder and director of the Center for Conservation Biology, and the author of over 600 scientific publications. The Eisenmann Medal is the highest award given by the Linnaean Society of New York. It is given to an individual for excellence in ornithology and encouragement of the amateur.

    Eisenmann Lecture: “Eagles of the Chesapeake,” presented by Dr. Bryan D. Watts

    Dr. Watts began his talk with an introduction to the Center of Conservation Biology, a research unit within the College of William and Mary. Its focus is on birds of conservation concern in the Western Hemisphere. The organization has worked on thousands of projects from Argentina to the Arctic, with about 40 field projects per year, many of which are long-term, multi-decade commitments. He then moved on to present three of those projects, starting with the Bald Eagles of Chesapeake Bay.

    The Eagles of Chesapeake Bay

    In his introductory description of the Chesapeake Bay, Dr. Watts noted that it is one of the great estuaries of the world, with shallow waters and a dendritic shoreline that result in a highly productive habitat, including for fish-eating birds such as the Bald Eagle, Osprey, and Great Blue Heron. It is also an area that is becoming engulfed in the rapid development of the Boston-to-Washington corridor and the Virginia Golden Crescent; the resultant habitat loss is having an impact on these species.

    Dr. Watts next talked about the Bald Eagles: their traits as part of the sea eagle subfamily, their habitat needs and preferences, and details about their life cycle, all punctuated with photos from around the Chesapeake Bay. He then moved on to the data, which illustrated the devastating effect of DDT on Bald Eagle populations, with maps of nesting sites around the Chesapeake Bay over time together with bar charts constructed from chronological data of nesting pairs. He described the monitoring methods, which amped up to aerial surveys beginning in 1962, and his own involvement flying as part of a team for over 30 years with the famous Professor Mitchell Byrd, and Captain Fuzzzo (with three “z’s,” with the middle “z” being silent…to spontaneous audience laughter).

    With the banning of DDT and the enactment of federal legislation directed at protection of endangered species, the Bald Eagle and Osprey populations have rebounded. Dr. Watts estimates that there are now 3,000 pairs of Bald Eagles in the Chesapeake Bay, up from about 60 to 70 pairs at the height of the DDT period. Osprey pairs have increased from 1,400 to around 12,000, and Great Blue Heron pairs from fewer than 1,000 to now 15,000. Over this time, there was an exponential growth in the birds’ reproduction, reaching a maximum in the late 1990s to early 2000s. Dr. Watts explained that research suggests that since that peak, a negative behavioral feedback loop is now bringing the populations to a new stable level based on territory constraints.

    The Chaco Eagle

    Dr. Watts introduced the Chaco Eagle (Buteogallus coronatus), which he described as one of the most endangered eagles in the world and one of the least known. It lives in arid habitats in south central South America in Argentina, Paraguay, and southern Brazil. Formerly named Crowned Eagle, it has a small crest of dark, gray feathers. Fifteen years ago the Center of Conservation Biology began assisting in conservation efforts with local researchers in Argentina to protect this eagle. The center provided technology and training to local scientists to learn about the ecology of the eagle, and to understand why it is so endangered.

    Included in the information the center learned is that Chaco Eagles’ principal prey are snakes and hairy armadillos; that they seem to produce a single chick per year; that the chick has a long dependency period of 12 months or longer; and that adults are dying at a rapid rate. As to why the adults are dying prematurely, field work has provided answers: 1) electrocution by power lines: rural infrastructure has not been upgraded to raptor-safe, international standards; 2) killing by ranchers: local lore tells of Chaco Eagles preying on lambs—a fiction, as borne out by research and evidence to the contrary.

    Addressing the indiscriminate killing of Chaco Eagles, Dr. Watts told us that an outreach and education program was developed and implemented to involve ranchers in the efforts to protect the species. He showed a photograph of himself demonstrating to a rancher how to band a Chaco Eagle. And he emphasized the need for multi-generational participation in these efforts in order to ensure sustainability of the species, showing another photo of a mother introducing her young daughter to a Chaco Eagle in-hand.

    Panama City—Remarkable Wetlands, Shorebirds, and Encroaching Development

    Dr. Watts concluded his lecture with a topic that he told the audience he had particularly selected to honor Eugene Eisenmann, having to do with Panama and the ecological treasure of the habitat near the Panama Canal.

    In 1997, at the time when the United States was handing over control of the Panama Canal Zone to Panama, the State Department asked Dr. Watts to do a rigorous assessment of waterbirds as part of its conservation recommendations to the Panamanians. One location was the shoreline just east of Panama City along the Pacific coast. Dr. Watts described it as a remarkable place, an internationally important area for migratory shorebirds with especially high densities of birds—on the order of 14 birds per meter. In 2008 he returned to Panama with the Center of Conservation Biology to do another survey. He found that the coastal mangrove forests and mudflats to the east of Panama City that they had surveyed in 1997 were being cut down and filled in to build high-rise buildings on this ecologically important terrain.

    Dr. Watts honed in on his theme: conservation must be local. And while research is important, conservation requires the commitment of the people who live there. In 1997 Dr. Watts had been concerned that the Panamanian people might not know how globally important the Panamanian Pacific coastline is for migratory shorebirds. At that time he wrote a booklet describing the birds and the importance of the habitat, and printed about 10,000 copies. He handed the booklets over to the Ministry of Education. Ten years later, in a classroom at one of the field sites he was visiting, he noticed one of those booklets tacked onto a bulletin board. And he had noticed over those ten to fifteen years that a national awareness and pride was building about the efforts to support shorebirds. In the early 2000s, the Panama Audubon Society directed their focus to shorebird conservation. To that end, the Center for Conservation Biology has periodically gone down to Panama to support them with equipment and training on shorebird survey techniques, all with the goal of building the capacity for local scientists and volunteers to do the work.

    Dr. Watts concluded that conservation requires the commitment of the local area, government entities, corporations, citizens, and citizen groups. And it needs to be multi-generational. We can offer help, but it is those who have the closest, local stake who ultimately will shepherd conservation forward.

    At 9:02 pm, following the Q&A session, President Debbie Mullins thanked Professor Watts and adjourned the meeting.

    Respectfully submitted by Lisa Kroop, Recording Secretary

    Linnaean Society of New York General Meeting Minutes—February 11, 2025

    This meeting and presentation took place entirely online via Zoom.

    At 7:00 pm, President Debbie Mullins called the Society meeting to order.

    President Mullins made the following announcements:

    • She welcomed all to the February meeting of the Linnaean Society of New York.
    • She noted that the annual meeting is just four weeks away, on Tuesday, March 11, at the Liederkranz Club on East 87th Street; it starts at 7:30 pm and is free of charge.
      • The meeting is for members only (those who are up-to-date with their dues).
      • There is still time to become a member in time to join the meeting. The membership application is on the Linnaean website at linnaeannewyork.org under Members/Join.
      • Those who have forgotten to pay their fall dues can pay now in order to attend the meeting.
      • Registration is online at members.linnaeannewyork.org/events
      • There will also be a cocktail reception before the meeting, starting at 6:00 pm. Tickets to the reception are $135 per person.
      • Among the awards being presented at the annual meeting are the following:
        • The Eisenmann Medal, the Society’s highest honor, to Dr. Brian Watts. He will give the keynote address, “Eagles of the Chesapeake”.
        • The Natural History Service Award to Dr. Dustin Partridge, Director of Conservation and Science at the New York City Bird Alliance.
        • The Shelda Taylor Award to Jennifer Stalec, a teacher at Eleanor Roosevelt High School.
      • Raffle tickets are $5. There will also be a silent auction with many offerings, including original art work by Alan Messer and a private boat tour of Jamaica Bay led by Don Riepe.
      • Volunteers are still needed for the evening. If you can help, email Debbie Mullins at president@linnaeannewyork.org.
    • President Mullins welcomed the following new Linnaean Society members:
      • Joseph McManus
      • Pieter Prall
      • Julia Zichello

    At 7:03 pm, President Mullins turned to the lecture program and introduced the speaker, Dr. Wesley Hochachka, senior research associate at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology in Ithaca, NY. Dr. Hochachka is an ornithologist with a background in field studies of birds and data analysis, and is part of the eBird organization. He has been working at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology since 1998.

    Lecture: “Informing Basic Science and Conservation with Bird Watchers’ Observations (and Lots of Computers),” presented by Dr. Wesley Hochachka

    Dr. Hochachka began his talk with a contextual overview of eBird, the citizen-science tool for worldwide bird data collection of the presence, location, and abundance of individual bird species. He explained that eBird provides the platform and system management support for birders to catalog their observations, and makes those observations available (in many forms) for researchers, organizations, and the general public.

    To give a sense of the scope and the range of the data within eBird, Dr. Hochachka gave the most recent number of total checklists submitted as of a few hours before this talk: 111 million. He observed that the data are not evenly distributed around the globe, illustrating with a world map. Not surprisingly, some of the highest concentrations of observations are in North America, parts of Europe, India, and elsewhere that eBird has developed partnerships and where eBird is widely used.

    This led to the next important point about eBird data that Dr. Hochachka made: in addition to the enormous amount of eBird being gathered, it is also “noisy,” in part because of the way it is gathered. The signal-to-noise ratio is very low, and methods are needed to identify patterns and trends from the data. Hence, the eBird organization has a data analysis team that works on many aspects of managing the data including: 1) developing methods to interpret them; 2) providing resources, documentation, and software tools for others to work with the data; and 3) conducting analyses using the supercomputer resources of the National Science Foundation’s ACCESS program to provide more manageable information and products.

    Dr. Hochachka presented examples of products that eBird is currently producing; those that are in the development stage; and others that are in areas for future work. From the “Status and Trends” project, Dr. Hochachka showed an abundance map and a trends map for Wood Thrush. Both the maps and the data underlying them are available to the public. Under development are “Trajectory” data products that aim to use eBird data to model species year-to-year abundance changes much like the results obtained from breeding bird surveys. Other ongoing projects are tailored for specific studies. Some work involves data analysis collaborations with partners on stewardship projects. Future data coordination and analysis might include audio recording data.

    Dr. Hochachka concluded his talk with a set of takeaways about eBird that he wanted to convey to the audience from his perspective as a data analyst:

    1. There are lots of data, albeit noisy data.
    2. Dealing with the noisiness requires lots of computation.
    3. We aim to direct this computation toward the useful goals of partners.
    4. eBird should never be considered a universal substitute for rigorously designed surveys.

    Following is Dr. Hochachka’s abstract of his talk.

    Formal bird monitoring programs, such as the North American Breeding Bird Survey, are invaluable sources of information about where birds live and how their numbers have changed through time. However, the costs of running such programs mean that they cannot be run throughout the year or across very large numbers of locations. The large quantities of information being collected by participatory (or citizen) science projects, most notably by eBird, have the potential to fill in gaps in our knowledge of bird populations. Careful analyses are needed in order to separate changes in bird populations from changes in the behavior of the bird watchers who provide their observations. In his presentation, he will talk about some of the insights into bird populations that have been revealed from eBird’s data and the uses of these insights. Weekly maps of the distributions of birds provide information about areas of concentration and migratory movements, which has been used to design and implement conservation programs and to inform policy decisions. Estimates of local changes in population size (“trend maps”) complement the information provided by the Breeding Bird Survey. He will conclude by describing some of our ongoing and future work, and plans for making the insights from eBird’s data more widely and easily available to a variety of audiences.

    At 7:53 pm, Vice President Doug Futuyma hosted the Q&A session.

    At the conclusion of the Q&A, Vice President Futuyma thanked Dr. Hochachka for his presentation, and noted that the number of questions clearly showed a great interest by the many birders who use eBird to understand how it works and what is being done with the data that is collected.

    At 8:36 pm the meeting was adjourned.

    The presentation has been recorded in its entirety, including the Q&A session and the president’s opening remarks. The recording is available for viewing on the Linnaean Society of New York website under the dropdown menu: Programs/Watch/ and on the Society’s YouTube channel, https://www.youtube.com/@linnaeanny/videos.

    Respectfully submitted by Lisa Kroop, Recording Secretary

    Linnaean Society of New York Regular Meeting Minutes—January 14, 2025

    This meeting and presentation took place entirely online via Zoom. 

    At 7:00 pm, President Debbie Mullins called the Society meeting to order. 

    President Mullins made the following announcements:

    She welcomed all to the first membership meeting of 2025.

    She announced that the 147th annual meeting will be held on Tuesday, March 11, at the Liederkranz Club on East 87thStreet. The Eisenmann Medal, the Society’s highest honor, will be presented to Dr. Brian Watts, and he will give the keynote address, Eagles of the Chesapeake.

    President Mullins noted that the annual meeting is only open to dues-paying members. Those who have forgotten to pay their fall dues can pay now and will be able to attend the meeting. She also encouraged non-members to join the Society, and come to the meeting, and remarked that the annual meetings are fun. The membership application is on the Linnaean website at linnaeannewyork.org under Members/Join.

    There will be a raffle and a silent auction to defray the costs of the meeting. Donations are welcome, either objects, or volunteering to lead an activity such as a guided bird walk.

    President Mullins provided an update on the New York State Horseshoe Crab Protection Act. Unfortunately, Governor Hochul vetoed the legislation over concerns about harming the commercial fishing industry in New York. The State Department of Environmental Conservation will continue to monitor and manage the horseshoe crab to protect the species. 

    President Mullins welcomed the following new Linnaean Society members:

    • Michelle Davis
    • Victoria Embuscado
    • Edward Gaillard
    • Madeeha Hanif
    • Brad Wells
    • Robert Young
    • Richard Zeman

    At 7:02 pm, President Mullins turned to the lecture program and introduced the speaker, Dr. Liz Derryberry, professor in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville. 

    Lecture: “Non-parallel Behavioral Responses to Soundscape Perturbations during the COVID-19 Pandemic,” presented by Dr. Liz Derryberry

    Dr. Derryberry did her doctoral work at Duke University on the cultural evolution of songs in White-crowned Sparrows, and she has continued to study this species for the past 25 years. In today’s lecture she described many attributes of the White-crowned Sparrow, including characteristics of its song, how it is a complex behavior (a phenotype), that both males and occasionally females sing, and that males sing for two main reasons: 1) to establish and protect territory; and 2) to attract females as potential mates. She also contrasted the singing of urban populations with rural ones, and described how background noise affects the way birds sing.

    Dr. Derryberry explained how birdsong can provide quantitative data to address research questions, including two of particular interest to her: 1) how does the environment affect the evolution of song, and, 2) what are the functional consequences of song evolution? Today’s lecture focused on a subset of these questions by considering the anthropogenic effect of the COVID-19 shutdown on the song of the White-crowned Sparrow. 

    Following is Dr. Derryberry’s abstract of her talk:

    The COVID-19 pandemic triggered unprecedented environmental perturbations—sometimes referred to collectively as the Anthropause—that have progressed rapidly and over broad spatial extents, affording novel quasi-experimental opportunities to measure outcomes of human-environment interactions. Here we evaluate the resilience of a common songbird to noise pollution by comparing soundscapes and songs across the San Francisco Bay Area prior to, during, and after the spring of 2020 statewide shutdown. Restrictions on human movement during the shutdown reduced noise pollution, relaxing auditory pressures on animals that communicate via sound. Birds quickly responded by producing wider bandwidth songs at lower amplitudes, effectively increasing signal efficacy and salience. In contrast, behavioral responses have lagged behind increasing noise levels as restrictions on human movement have loosened over time. Although song amplitude eventually returned to pre-pandemic levels, paralleling noise levels, birds have continued to produce wide bandwidth songs, with consequences for signal masking in noise. These findings illustrate that behavioral traits are slower to change in response to newly adverse conditions, indicating non-parallel responses to noise pollution removal and re-introduction.

    At 7:43 pm, Vice President Doug Futuyma thanked Dr. Derryberry, saying that the White-crowned Sparrow is a fascinating species that has been studied a lot, and that Dr. Derryberry has made it even more so. He then hosted the Q&A session.

    At the conclusion of the Q&A, Vice President Futuyma thanked Dr. Derryberry again, and at 8:13 pm the meeting was adjourned.

    The presentation has been recorded in its entirety, including the Q&A session and the president’s opening remarks. The recording is available for viewing on the Linnaean Society of New York website under the dropdown menu: Programs/Watch/ and on the Society’s YouTube channel, https://www.youtube.com/@linnaeanny/videos

    Respectfully submitted by Lisa Kroop, Recording Secretary

    Linnaean Society of New York Regular Meeting Minutes—December 10, 2024

    This meeting and presentation took place entirely online via Zoom.

    At 7:00 pm, President Debbie Mullins called the Society meeting to order.

    President Mullins made the following announcements:

    The Christmas Bird Count begins this weekend; the Brooklyn count is Saturday and the New York County count is Sunday. Registration is required; the form to register can be found on the New York City Bird Alliance website. For counties outside of New York City, information can be found on the New York State Ornithological Association website, nysoa.org.

    Governor Hochul still has not signed the New York State Horseshoe Crab Protection Act, and there are only a few days left to do so. The bill puts forth measures to help protect horseshoe crabs, whose numbers have dropped to unhealthy levels. President Mullins noted that New Jersey and Connecticut already have legislation in place. She encouraged people to contact Governor Hochul tonight by email using this address: correspondence.office@exec.ny.gov.

    Field trips will resume in January, and more volunteers are needed to serve as registrars to manage the trips. Please send an email to trips@linnaeannewyork.org if you would like to volunteer to become a trip registrar.

    President Mullins welcomed the following new Linnaean Society members:

    • Signe Hammer
    • Stephen Kelly
    • Mary Kentros
    • Steven Kessler
    • Anne Swaim
    • Shaul Yahil

    President Mullins invited non-member attendees to join the Society. The membership application is on the Society website.

    At 7:04 pm, President Mullins turned to the lecture program and introduced the speaker, Dr. Christina P. Riehl, associate professor of ecology and evolutionary biology at Princeton University. Dr. Riehl is a fellow of the American Ornithological Society, and editor-in-chief of the journal Ornithology.

    Lecture: “Cheaters and Collaborators: The Evolution of Cooperative Breeding in a Tropical Bird,” presented by Dr. Christina P. Riehl

    The tropical bird referenced in Dr. Riehl’s lecture title is the Greater Ani, a Central and South American species in the cuckoo family that Dr. Riehl has been studying for nearly twenty years. She shared her fascination with these birds, giving an in-depth discussion of where and how they live and their behavior, and described her research on their unusual breeding system and its evolution.

    Dr. Riehl does field work in central Panama in the middle of the Panama Canal, at Barro Colorado Island. It is a tropical habitat, and the Greater Ani live there year-round. During breeding season, to protect their nests from depredation, the birds nest in the emergent vegetation along the shoreline, or in tree branches that hang over the water’s edge. Access for observation, banding and DNA sampling is by motorboat, and remote monitoring by camera.

    Dr. Riehl described the breeding strategies of the Greater Ani. They are communal nesters like the other species of their genus, but unlike them, the Greater Ani seem to be obligate cooperative breeders (they must nest with more than one pair): in all the years that Dr. Riehl has been observing the Greater Ani, she has never found a nest with a lone pair. And, echoing a strategy that cuckoos are well-known for, Greater Ani are also parasitic breeders.

    Greater Ani Communal and Cooperative Nesting

    Both males and females from at least two breeding pairs contribute to building a single nest. The females lay their eggs in the same nest, and all parents share the parental care. Females cannot recognize which eggs are theirs, nor which chicks. Some nesting groups also include a non-breeding helper that assists in raising the young (often an offspring from the previous year of one of the breeding pairs); this behavior is referred to as cooperative breeding rather than communal breeding. Cooperative breeders are rare in North America, but one example is the Florida Scrub Jay.

    Why did this system of communal/cooperative breeding evolve? Why not breed as monogamous pairs with biparental care as most birds do? Dr. Riehl identified some of the costs of cooperative breeding. One has to do with the female competitive behavior shown by females during the initial part of the egg laying phase: until a female has laid her own egg, she will eject any egg that she finds in the nest. Once she starts laying eggs, she stops pushing any eggs out of the nest, likely because she would risk destroying her own. This behavior also likely limits the upper number of breeding pairs sharing a nest: when more females are present, more eggs get ejected; in that case, what normally happens is that either the nest is abandoned, or some of the pairs leave the group. Dr. Riehl looked at data to see if there was something that would predict which female would lay first, and which would lay last, but found no clue. Eventually, however, in the course of several breeding cycles, each female got to be the first one to lay its egg; thus the cost of losing eggs was equally shared across the breeding group.

    One of the benefits to nesting in groups is that it provides protection of the eggs from predators. For the Greater Ani, predators are monkeys and snakes, and the anis will mob them to keep them away from the nest. Furthermore, the loss of eggs due to nest predation is substantially greater than the losses due to competitive egg-tossing out of the nest by the females. It would seem that larger numbers of nesting pairs would be more effective against predators, and Dr. Riehl shared graphical data which seemed to support that assumption. But further evaluation led her to a different conclusion: it turns out that weather patterns also have an impact on the success rate of reproduction that can cancel out the benefits of large nesting group size. During years with wet conditions during the breeding season, the nests with larger numbers of pair groups do indeed do better than smaller groups; however, Dr. Riehl noticed that during cycles of the El Nino-Southern Oscillation, which result in a dry period in Panama and hence not much food, the anis do poorly, and the groups with many nesting pairs do far worse than two-pair groups. Hence the costs and benefits of the size of the group vary over time depending on the weather patterns, and the reproductive difference between two-pair and three-pair groups averages out over time.

    Conspecific Brood Parasitism

    Until recently not recognized, Greater Anis also breed by conspecific brood parasitism, meaning a female will lay her egg in the nest of another of her own species. At first, when Dr. Riehl came upon an egg with a genotype that didn’t match any of the females in the group, she assumed it was a genotyping error; but at some point, her team began to observe that females who were not part of the social group would approach a nest, and be chased off. This seemed to suggest the possibility of parasitic eggs (eggs laid by a Greater Ani outsider, not of the same social group), which they ultimately concluded was the case.

    Dr. Riehl noted that the prevailing hypothesis for how this communal breeding system evolved was through conspecific brood parasitism behavior, and she is interested in understanding the costs and benefits of parasitism. By observing the Greater Ani nests, Dr. Riehl’s team followed the changes in the appearance of the eggs during incubation, and watched to see if the nesting birds could recognize a parasitic egg, particularly when it was laid at the wrong time (because in that situation the egg would likely look different than those of the host clutch). A female would often would eject the parasitic egg. Parasitic eggs that do manage to be incubated with the host eggs still have a low hatching success. Why, then, do females act as parasitic layers? Because Dr. Riehl has been collecting data for so many years, she was able to analyze around 2,000 eggs collected over a ten year period, and identified 65 parasitic eggs whose mothers she could track. Of those, 55 were laid by females who were part of social groups. She concluded that they had begun the breeding season as cooperators, but if their nest was depredated while they were still laying, a minority of them would parasitically place their eggs in another Greater Ani social group’s nest.

    Dr. Riehl concluded her talk by encouraging those in the audience who might go birding in the tropics to look out for anis, identify which are Smooth-billed, Grooved-billed and Greater, watch their very interesting communal behavior, and look under their nests to see if there are piles of rejected eggs.

    At 7:51 pm, Vice President Doug Futuyma told Dr. Riehl how much he enjoyed her fascinating talk. He then hosted the Q&A session, which covered more details about the Greater Ani, including their lineage and connections to other cuckoos.

    At the conclusion of the Q&A, Vice President Futuyma thanked Dr. Riehl for a marvelous talk about a fascinating species and a fascinating life history, and at 8:15 pm the meeting was adjourned.

    A recording of this meeting in its entirety can be found on the Linnaean Society of New York website.

    Respectfully submitted by Lisa Kroop, Recording Secretary

    Linnaean Society of New York Regular Meeting Minutes—November 12, 2024

    This meeting and presentation took place entirely online via Zoom.

    At 7:00 pm, President Debbie Mullins called the Society meeting to order.

    President Mullins made the following announcements:

    The Linnaean field trip schedule is on the Society’s website, with trips through August of 2025. While non-members are welcome to join the Society’s trips, registration priority is given to Linnaean members.

    President Mullins encouraged non-members to join the Society.

    Membership renewal dues have still not been received from quite a few members. President Mullins reminded the remaining members to submit their dues as soon as possible.

    In October, the board of directors voted to eliminate the Society’s requirement for sponsorship for new members.

    At the November board meeting, board members expressed approval for dropping the requirement that new members be voted in by the board and the membership. Members are encouraged to share their opinions about dropping the voting requirement by emailing President Mullins at president@linnaeannewyork.org.

    The board hopes that eliminating sponsorship and voting approval of new members will send a clear signal that all who have an interest in birds and natural history are welcome to become members of the Society.

    Registration for the upcoming 125th annual Christmas Bird Count for the New Jersey, Lower Hudson count circle (which includes Manhattan) is open on the NYC Bird Alliance (formerly NYC Audubon) website. The CBC date is December 15th.

    Society members had been asked to vote online on two motions in advance of this meeting:

    Motion 1: Request to approve the minutes of the October, 2024, regular members meeting. The minutes were approved by a vote of 103 in favor, six abstaining, and none opposed.

    Motion 2: Request to approve the membership applications of sixteen new members. The new memberships were approved with 146 in favor, one abstaining, and none opposed. President Mullins warmly welcomed the following new members:

    • Melissa Breyer, Active
    • Cheryl Craddock, Active
    • Michelle, D’Mello, Active
    • Rosemary Feal, Associate
    • George Gianakos, Active
    • Craig Himmelwright, Associate
    • Richard Lufrano, Active
    • David Minoli, Active
    • Sahar Sehgaal, Active
    • Anna Taam, Active
    • Adrianne Waite, Associate
    • Julia Deng, Active
    • Lisa Wolfe, Active
    • Thomas Freedman, Active
    • Sarah Kimball Stephenson, Active
    • Erasmus van Niekerk, Associate

    At 7:05 pm, President Mullins turned to the lecture program and introduced the speaker, Dr. Kelly Zamudio, professor in the Department of Integrative Biology at the University of Texas, Austin, and an endowed fellow of the Doherty Regents Chair in Molecular Biology.

    Lecture: “Diversification and Conservation of Neotropical Amphibians,” presented by Dr. Kelly Zamudio

    Dr. Zamudio’s presentation covered three topics related to diversification and conservation of neotropical amphibians: 1) sexual selection and mating systems; 2) ecology and evolution of infectious diseases; and 3) rediscovery of lost frogs.

    Sexual selection and mating systems

    Dr. Zamudio gave a historical perspective and detailed description of the diversity of frogs’ reproductive modes, an area of study that her lab is interested in. She explained that for decades, accepted dogma was that frogs evolved from aquatic to terrestrial breeding in order to achieve higher reproduction fitness by avoiding predation, since it is safer for eggs to develop out of the water. She cited a 2013 publication that systematically reviewed frog reproductive modes, showing how they were evolving. The paper concluded that selective pressure from predation was causing reproductive phenotypes to evolve.

    Dr. Zamudio and her colleagues believed that sexual selection might also play a role. They therefore conducted a study to investigate whether sexual selection might be driving the changes in reproductive modes. They concluded that sexual selection played a role, in addition to predation, and published a paper, “Polyandry, Predation, and the Evolution of Frog Reproductive Modes.”

    Dr. Zamudio postulates that a lot of the diversity in frog reproductive modes is highly underestimated, and that more can be learned from individual species-specific details. She then gave examples of two recent studies: 1) “Male-male Competition and Repeated Evolution of Terrestrial Breeding in Atlantic Coastal Forest Frogs” by her graduate student, Fabio de Sa, et al., which determined the changes in the degree of dimorphism caused by several switches between stream breeding and terrestrial breeding over evolutionary time; and 2) “Show Me You Care: Female Mate Choice Based on Egg Attendance Rather than Male or Territorial Traits,” by Anyelet Valencia-Aguilar, whose work on glass frogs in the southwestern Amazon focused on parental care and reproductive success.

    Ecology and Evolution of Infectious Diseases

    There is a worldwide pandemic affecting frogs from the fungal pathogen, Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis (Bd). Bd has played a role in the decline of 501 species of amphibians in the past 50 years, with the extinction of 90 species, and a 90% population reduction in another 124 species. Dr. Zamudio showed charts to illustrate global locations, timeframes, extents of loss, and phylogeny, indicating that East Asia is the source for the Bd lineages. Dr. Zamudio has been doing a number of studies focusing on the genetics and genomics of the infection process. She described one study of Eastern spotted salamanders. While Bd has spread worldwide, the salamander-specific fungus Batrachochytrium salamandrivorans (Bsal) has not yet reached the Americas. Dr. Zamudio’s student, Ana Longo, conducted laboratory studies to investigate the consequences of co-infections of Bd and Bsal on host survival, and found the lowest survival rate when the salamanders were doubly infected by both Bd and Bsal (2019 paper: “Double-trouble: Co-infections of Chytrid Fungi Will Severely Impact Widely Distributed Newts”).

    Rediscovery of Lost Frogs Using Environmental DNA

    Half of the amphibian species in Brazil are distributed in the Atlantic coastal forest, an area now fragmented and around 16% of its original size. Species populations have declined, been extirpated, and become extinct. Potentially, though, some of the species that aren’t being seen might still be around. Dr. Zamudio’s group visited several locations in the Atlantic coastal forest, and used environmental DNA (eDNA) techniques to look for traces of “lost” frogs. Their work with eDNA analysis identified seven frog species: four were species with declining populations, two were species that had locally disappeared but were found elsewhere, and one was a species that had been considered extinct. These findings provide another piece of data towards understanding what species are still present and deserving of further conservation action.

    At 7:57 pm, Linnaean member Jim Muchmore thanked Dr. Zamudio for a fascinating lecture. He then hosted the Q&A session.

    At the conclusion of the Q&A, Jim Muchmore thanked Dr. Zamudio again, and at 8:15 pm the meeting was adjourned.

    A recording of this meeting in its entirety can be found on the Linnaean Society of New York website.

    Respectfully submitted by Lisa Kroop, Recording Secretary

    Linnaean Society of New York Regular Meeting Minutes—October 8, 2024

    This meeting and presentation took place entirely online via Zoom.

    At 7:00 pm, President Debbie Mullins welcomed the attendees and called the Society meeting to order.

    President Mullins made the following announcements:
    Membership dues fund the Society’s programs and activities and are the Society’s largest source of income. President Mullins thanked those who have already paid and explained to those who haven’t how they can pay online, or by mailing a check.
    New York City Council legislation, Intro 896, (Lights Out bill) is pending. The proposed bill would require privately owned commercial and industrial buildings to turn off nonessential nighttime illumination during peak bird migration. President Mullins encouraged the members of the audience to write or call their city council member to urge sponsorship of this bill. Artificial light is responsible for attracting and disorienting migrating birds, resulting in high mortality from window collisions.

    Society members had been asked to vote online on two motions in advance of this meeting:  

    Motion 1: Request to approve the minutes of the September, 2024, regular meeting. The minutes were approved by a vote of 128 in favor, four abstaining, and none opposed.

    Motion 2: Request to approve the membership applications of ten new members. The new memberships were approved with 131 in favor, one abstaining, and none opposed. President Mullins warmly welcomed the following new members:

    • David Berger
    • Alison Dundy
    • Ann Goodwin
    • Stevan Hubbard
    • Peggy Maslow
    • Joseph Navarro
    • Lindsay Drogin
    • Nancy Rosenberg
    • Susan Klingelhoefer
    • Joan Cade

    President Mullins again welcomed all the new members to the Linnaean Society, said that she was happy they had joined, and looked forward to meeting them soon. She also invited the non-member attendees to join the Society, explaining that the Society is open to everyone who has an interest in birds or other areas of natural science and that the membership application is on the Society’s website.

    At 7:03 pm, President Mullins turned to the lecture program and introduced the speaker, Dr. Andrew Farnsworth, a visiting scientist in the Center for Avian Population Studies at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology and director of BirdCast—a massive collaborative research and development project working to model the dynamics of bird migration.

    Lecture: “Bird Migration in the Era of Big Data: BirdCast Perspectives on the Future of Monitoring Migrating Birds,” presented by Dr. Andrew Farnsworth

    This evening’s lecture, like that of last month’s, once again addressed the tragic population loss of nearly three billion birds in North America over the past fifty years.  This time the focus was on the development of quantitative tools—BirdCast, its predecessors, and other methods under development—and their power to better understand bird migration and promote solutions to reverse population declines, particularly in migrating bird species.

    Dr. Farnsworth began by giving a historical perspective demonstrating how far we have come in the evaluation of bird migration data. Thanks to technological developments, especially those evolving in the digital age, the amount of bird data has exploded along with analytical abilities to identify patterns, trends, and relationships from enormous quantities of data. He described the first coordinated scientific effort to quantify nocturnal bird migration across the continental United States. During four October nights in the early 1950s, hundreds of observers trained telescopes on the moon and counted the silhouettes of birds. It took almost fifteen years to analyze and publish the results. In addition, early in the development of radar technology it was recognized that birds were being detected on radar scans. Weather radar scans from this period were recorded on 16 mm and 35 mm film. Correlating the moon-watching data with weather surveillance radar data became one of the foundational approaches to the development of the BirdCast bird migration quantification model. Today, computer power, big data analysis techniques, and machine learning are being harnessed to interpret and manage the enormous quantities of data and to present information in close to real-time on the BirdCast platform.

    Moving on to BirdCast itself, Dr. Farnsworth presented a map of the United States showing all the weather surveillance radar locations, with weather superimposed and blue blotches (which are the birds) around many of the radar locations. Next he showed an example of a BirdCast live bird migration map recorded on October 6, 2023, at 22:20 ET, and described many of its features. He noted that this particular night marked the largest migration night ever recorded on BirdCast; he hopes that conservation work will cause this number to increase. The migration map he showed was on a continental scale, but BirdCast also provides information at state and county levels; to illustrate, he showed New York County examples from 2021, 2022, 2023, and 2024. The 2024 panel was particularly notable. It was from three nights before, on October 5th, when the largest number of birds yet recorded in the BirdCast/dashboard era occurred in Manhattan, with over one million crossing over the county—an estimated 1,028,300 birds.

    From the perspective of bird conservation, one of the powerful outcomes of the BirdCast project has been the ability to reliably forecast bird migration—both the numbers and the locations of where the birds are going to be. This has big implications for reducing bird collisions with buildings and windows—a major cause of the decline in populations of migrating birds. Dr. Farnsworth talked about how lights attract and disorient birds, pointing out that untreated glass can be deadly, but when lights are turned off, typical migration behavior resumes.

    BirdCast migration forecasting, in tandem with initiatives for turning out lights on high migration nights, can substantially reduce the number of bird collisions and fatalities, as can bird-safe window designs and retrofits. Dr. Farnsworth cited the example of McCormick Place, an enormous, glass-faced convention center in Chicago along the shoreline of Lake Michigan that is directly on the Mississippi Flyway. For decades, it has been the site of large numbers of bird collisions and resulting deaths, especially during bird migration. A particularly high number of bird fatalities on the night of October 4-5, 2023, received a lot of press. McCormick Place installed bird-safe window film in September, 2024, and now participates in the Lights Out Chicago program, closing drapes at night, and reducing lighting during peak migration periods. Dr. Farnsworth has heard that since these changes were made, the number of collisions has dropped dramatically for the first time in forty years. He cited other examples of successful Lights Outs programs and bird-safe design, and hopes that they will bring an awareness and motivation for bird conservation around the world.

    Dr. Farnsworth’s final topic was evolving technologies for using big data in the study of bird migration. He talked about the identification of birds by sound, and collecting and analyzing flight calls of nocturnal migrating birds. He also discussed the potential to use today’s technology to analyze the pre-digital migration radar data from the 1950s and 60s in order to gain more understanding of historical migration: the intensity of migration, where it was occurring, its relationship to weather, and how it has changed. He talked about remote sensing, and how it might be used to understand bird biology and behavior interacting in the atmosphere—for example, when unusual events occur, like hurricane Milton. He also mentioned thermal photography as a way to identify bird migration at night.

    And why go to all this effort, gathering all this data, pooling community input, analyzing it all?  The bottom line is that understanding the science allows us to make changes that will reverse this “horrible curve” and thereby increase bird populations.

    At 8:00 pm, Vice President Doug Futuyma thanked Dr. Farnsworth for a fantastic talk, saying that it had been amazing. He then hosted the Q&A session.

    At the conclusion of the Q&A, Vice President Futuyma thanked Dr. Farnsworth again for a really, really interesting talk, and at 8:32 pm the meeting was adjourned.

    A recording of this meeting in its entirety can be found on the Linnaean Society of New York website.

    Respectfully submitted by Lisa Kroop, Recording Secretary

    Linnaean Society Meeting Minutes—September 10, 2024

    This meeting and presentation took place entirely online via Zoom.

    At 7:00 p.m., President Debbie Mullins called the Society meeting to order and welcomed the attendees to this first meeting of the Linnaean Society’s new program year.

    The annual Linnaean homecoming picnic is being held on Sunday, September 22, at Central Park’s Summit Rock, with a rain date of September 29. President Mullins encouraged members and their guests to come. In addition, there will be a bird walk for beginners that morning in the North Woods of Central Park. RSVP is through the Linnaean website.

    President Mullins announced that next month, at the October board meeting, the board of directors will vote to eliminate the sponsorship requirement for prospective members. The board has come to the opinion that this requirement can be a barrier for people who want to join, and may be giving a false impression that the Society is not open to all applicants. It is hoped that removing the sponsorship requirement will send a strong signal that the Society welcomes everyone with an interest in birds and natural history to become a Linnaean member.

    Society members had been asked to vote online on two motions in advance of this meeting:

    Motion 1: Request to approve the minutes of the May, 2024 regular meeting. The minutes were approved by a vote of 100 in favor, 5 abstaining, and none opposed.

    Motion 2: Request to approve the membership applications of fifteen new members. The vote was unanimous with 105 in favor, none opposed, and none abstaining. President Mullins warmly welcomed the following new members:

    • James Jackson, Active Membership, Sponsored by Brian Whipple
    • Emily Tenenbaum, Active Membership, Sponsored by Kristin Ellington
    • Andrea Trigueros, Active Membership, Sponsored by Junko Suzuki
    • Thierry Breyette, Active Membership, Sponsored by Richard Davis
    • Ruby Grewal, Supporting Membership, Sponsored by David Spawn
    • Ann Wenzel, Active Membership, Sponsored by Kristin Ellington
    • Catherine (Kitty) Stanton, Active Membership, Sponsored by Mary Beth Kooper
    • Stephen Ogunbiyi, Associate Membership, Sponsored by Mary Beth Kooper
    • Catherine Payson, Active Membership, Sponsored by Amanda Bielskas
    • Christie Tashjian, Active Membership, Sponsored by Mary Normandia
    • Val Coleman, Active Membership, Sponsored by Samari Weinberg
    • Xiao Li, Active Membership, Sponsored by Bonnie Eissner
    • Emily Jones, Active Membership, Sponsored by Amanda Bielskas
    • Katharine Cobb, Supporting Membership, Sponsored by Suzanne Zywicki
    • Ronit (Row) Wrubel, Active Membership, Sponsored by Amanda Bielskas

    President Mullins again welcomed all the new members to the Linnaean Society, and expressed the hope that they will participate on some field trips and programs, get involved in the work of the Society, and come to the homecoming picnic to be greeted in person.

    President Mullins reminded all renewing members to pay their membership dues for the upcoming year. Instructions were emailed to all members on September 6, 2024.

    At 7:04 p.m., President Mullins turned to the lecture program and introduced the speaker, Dr. Brooke Bateman, Senior Director of Climate and Community Science at the National Audubon Society. Dr. Bateman collaborates with scientists, volunteers, and Audubon’s Climate Initiative team to develop research on climate and bird conservation, including the National Audubon 2019 report, “Survival by Degrees: 389 Bird Species on the Brink.” She is the science director of Climate Watch, and works with community volunteers to study how climate change affects birds in North America. Dr. Bateman shared some of her work at Audubon, connecting studies of biodiversity and climate change science to on-the-ground conservation, public engagement, and policy action.

    Lecture: “Birds Tell Us: Connecting Biodiversity and Climate Science to on the Ground Conservation, Public Engagement, and Policy Actions” presented by Dr. Brooke Bateman

    Dr. Bateman began her talk by invoking Rachel Carson, and her influential book, “Silent Spring,” which brought to national awareness the deleterious changes to living things up and down the food chain from the scaled-up use of pesticides and other industrial chemicals in our environment. The impact of Rachel Carson’s book sparked the environmental movement, and actions to protect the environment ensued.

    Dr. Bateman then pivoted to today, and the observation that we are in the midst of a biodiversity crisis. She showed a graph from the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) showing the percent of extinctions for vertebrate categories from the years 1500 to 2018, and the acceleration of extinctions across the animal world since 1900. Birds were one of the groups, and the 2019 report that North America has lost 2.9 billion—one in four birds—since 1970 highlights the crisis. Dr. Bateman gave some examples of birds lost since 1970—2.5 billion migratory birds; 2-in-5 Baltimore Orioles, 170 million eastern forest birds, 6-in-10 Wood Thrushes—and then asked, “So, what are the reasons?” She presented a slide that showed annual fatalities in North America from cats (2.6 billion), windows (624 million), vehicles (214 million), and industrial collisions (64 million), but the overriding reasons for bird population loss are habitat loss and degradation, and, more recently, climate change.

    The National Audubon Society has a commitment to change the trend of declining bird populations. Scientific studies, climate science, community science, public engagement and action are all part of Audubon’s approach to achieving that aim, and Dr. Bateman described some of these programs:

    • A recent Audubon study (“Unraveling a Century of Global Change Impacts on Winter Bird Distributions in the Eastern United States”) highlighted the dual crises of climate change and biodiversity loss using Christmas Bird Count data going back nearly a century. Dr. Bateman showed graphics from this study demonstrating how land use changes and climate change have impacted bird species populations.
    • A 2019 development project, “Survival by Degrees: 389 Bird Species on the Brink,” is a modeling tool linking climate science with public engagement, based on present and future climate conditions, human land use, habitat types and locations, and surface water data. It is on the National Audubon website, and is an interactive program that allows the public to see how bird species populations may respond to climate change for different warming scenarios: 1.5°C, 2.0°C, and 3.0°C (global average temperature above the pre-industrial level). The tool shows ranges on both a national and local scale for each season. Dr. Bateman explained the rationale for selecting 1.5°C, 2.0°C, and 3.0°C by showing a chart with warming projections for the year 2100 assuming different policies and actions, and pledges and targets, and gave as context the fact that the world was at 1.2°C in 2022. Audubon’s conclusions from this project included: 1) two-thirds of North American bird species are at risk of extinction from climate change; 2) if climate change can be stabilized to below 2°C, 76% of North American bird species at risk will have an improved chance for survival; 3) under the 3°C scenario, 98% of the coterminous United States could be affected by one or more climate-related threats and 305 bird species will face three or more threats, while at 1.5°C, 34 bird species will face three or more climate-related threats; and, 4) every bird species will experience some kind of impact from climate change.

    Dr. Bateman described some of the National Audubon Society’s approaches to action on climate change that connect science to community engagement and policy action:

    • Publishing scientific papers, thereby communicating science studies and conclusions that are peer-reviewed for credibility.
    • Communicating to the general public—for example, an article, “Birds Can’t Fight Climate Change. We Can.,” in the Audubon Climate Change magazine.
    • Development of the National Audubon website for the public to explore, get information about birds, climate change, and learn about issues.
    • Localizing information, addressing changes on a local scale—for example, a scientific paper about how US National Wildlife Refuges are likely to see species changes due to climate change.
    • Bringing findings to legislators, and engage them—for example, demonstrating the “Surviving by Degrees” tool to federal and state policymakers and showing them results—that is, the consequences of potential climate change in their own ZIP Codes.
    • Distributing an award-winning Audubon climate action guide that can be used by community volunteers and leaders.
    • Publicizing climate change through art—for example, the Audubon Mural Project, which commissions artists to paint murals portraying bird species threatened by climate change on walls, doors, and other surfaces around throughout New York City.
    • Communicating to large audiences, on television, in national and regional newspapers, and on social media.
    • Engaging community advocates, especially Audubon chapters, nature centers, and other partners.

    Dr. Bateman next turned to the topic of clean energy, giving some examples of the ways National Audubon has been helping guide policies for addressing climate change and helping birds:

    • In Washington state, with Audubon Washington: contributed to historic clean energy legislation that requires all electricity to come from carbon-free sources by 2045.
    • In Arkansas, National Audubon advocated for the Solar Access Act of 2019, which triples the size limit of solar installations for commercial net metering customers; permits rooftop solar customers to sell power back to the grid; and allows 3rd party ownership (leasing).
    • In Alabama, thanks in part to efforts by Audubon members across the state, the South Carolina legislature unanimously passed the Energy Freedom Act, which expands net metering, encourages large scale and community solar projects, and enhances energy choice.
    • National Audubon developed a clean energy policy report, “Birds and Transmission: Building the Grid Birds Need,” that identified the locations where transmission grids are likely to expand and where they are currently being planned, so that Audubon can promote bird-friendly decisions at the project level. Dr. Bateman described an example, the SunZia Transmission Project, one of the largest clean energy infrastructure projects in American history, spanning 500 miles between central New Mexico and south central Arizona. Audubon collaborated with the project to address bird-related protections in the design considerations for routing, siting of towers, installation, and tower design.

    Natural climate solutions are another focus of National Audubon as it tackles biodiversity loss and climate change. They indicate paths for both climate adaptation and climate mitigation. Natural climate solutions include protection, restoration, and improved land management actions that increase carbon storage or avoid greenhouse gas emissions in landscapes and wetlands across the globe. Dr. Bateman explained the considerations that go into these solutions and gave examples of this approach, making mention of an Audubon report, “Audubon’s Natural Climate Solutions Report: Maintaining and Restoring Natural Habitats to Help Mitigate Climate Change.” This report presents a path forward to simultaneously understanding what areas can support birds and where to stabilize climate change.

    Dr. Bateman concluded her presentation by emphasizing the importance of taking national science knowledge and bringing it to the local level, so that it connects with people and engages them, promoting an understanding of climate change and showing how to focus efforts moving forward. Her final slide and comments again quoted Rachel Carson: “The human race is challenged more than ever before to demonstrate our mastery, not over nature but of ourselves.”

    At 8:00 p.m., Past President Rochelle Thomas thanked Dr. Bateman for a great talk. She then hosted the Q&A session.

    At the conclusion of the Q&A, Past President Rochelle Thomas thanked Dr. Bateman again for a great presentation, and at 8:17 p.m. the meeting was adjourned.

    A recording of this meeting in its entirety can be found on the Linnaean Society of New York website.

    Respectfully submitted by Lisa Kroop, Recording Secretary